the death of immortality
The current issue of PN Review contains an article by Raymond Tallis called "The Death of Immortality." For some reason I read this article with mounting joy which ended in actual out-loud laughter, as if it were a work of art and I were experiencing perfect happiness, like when I read War and Peace.
It begins:
'Man,' Yeats famously claimed, 'has created death'. This is manifestly untrue: evolutionary theory tells us that man was created out of death. H. sapiens grew out of a rising pyramid of the unsurviving unfit. What Yeats really meant was that Man, uniquely, has made death explicit. In us, transience, the condition of all things, has been transformed into a tragic mystery black-edged with terror. And so we have invented immortality, to cancel the certainty of physical death with the promise of eternal life. Unfortunately, the idea of immortality may itself be proving mortal.
A page and a half of delightful argument follow, & then this:
Anyway, we can't all be famous. The dead compete with one another for the divided and distracted attention of the living. One person's posthumous glory requires the obscurity of thousands of fellow humans. If fame were apportioned equally, no one would be famous. Signals such as 'Shakespeare' would be lost in the noise. Every supernova dims established stars: even Zadie Smith steals a little of Homer's radiance.
It ends:
How fortunate, then, that we are shallow, so that our dread of extinction is not as frequent, and rarely as intense, as our sexual desires, our longing for sleep, or our fear of embarrassment. And when the blessing of shallowness fails us, we might recall Imre Kertesz's claim that 'the smallest instant of life is stronger than the death that denies it', and try to imagine this as if it were true.








No comments:
Post a Comment