Tuesday, 17 July 2007

dear Antonia Quirke...

It's not often that I get the impulse to write to the author of a book I've been reading.* Well, you know: we'd all like to write a letter to Louis MacNeice (I can do with poets what you do with movie stars; don't you agree that Louis is divine? I originally read him just because he was so handsome),** of course. At least, I would if he were alive.

But this week I've been reading your book, and I want to write to you because I have a feeling you'd like to hear how much you've made me laugh! And weep with delirious recognition! I feel as if I know you (not in a creepy stalker way, rather in a girls-living-this-strange-life-in-London too kind of way. By the way).

Your memoir, covering your romantic history interlaced with your rather madcap career as a film critic (and incidentally I never could stomach Jaws, but now I want to get your book on it: is it really underrated??), really brings out the crazy way in which some of us - I admit, I think it is just some of us - seem to experience our own lives through some sort of a filter. (You have a great name for it: the "perforated screening mechanism." I LOVE this.) You know, was it the movies that were more real, or the boyfriends? And how do these models create our lives? (I think I had a flash of this the other day when I was watching The History Boys. The part where Posner starts performing as Celia Johnson in the last scene in Brief Encounter took me so aback that I was in tears! It was so familiar, as if written on my own skin - though, since what happened to Ewan MacGregor in that Peter Greenaway film, let's not mention that idea - it was almost more real than anything else.)

There were so many bits in "this mad, marvellous, film-crazed memoir" (Kate Saunders, The Times) that had me laughing out loud inappropriately - on buses, in the hospital outpatients corridor, even in shops I was laughing as I read - that I can't even think of half of them. I loved your "men-bender" - the Cuban bartender, Ilana's divorce lawyer (Ilana sounds great), and all the others, all rolled (in the hay) up in one overthetoply long sentence that goes on forever and ever just like that day, or was it three days, all in one... Oh my God! It made me wish I was 25 again. (It takes a lot to do that.) That scene where you got so drunk with Tom Paulin before going on the Late Show is so deliciously exquisite that I felt it like pain. All those italics! and that jab! "... some kind of - I don't know, a Boody Mary or something, some kind of new-fangled intravenous hangover cure" - just too much. I loved you then.

I have to mention your opening scene, the one where you hyperventilate watching Brando at the age of ten, so that everybody thinks you're dying and they call the ambulance. This makes me laugh every single time I think of it. I wish I'd done that. I was too busy being Harriet the Spy.

Mind you , sweetie, I think you got a couple of those film stars wrong. I know - strong words - but really. (BTW, loved the Jeff Bridges-as-Aslan bit.) In short, I think you've misread Sam Neill! He does have that amazing solidity, but he is always, always, tinged with menace - or inadequacy, rather, a certain dangerous kind of inadequacy. Of course that's why they gave him the part in The Piano, to say nothing of My Brilliant Career (a film that had such an effect on me when I was 17 that it virtually changed the way I perceived the whole world. I felt I had just been born in that cinema! Alas, I had afterwards to change the way I perceived Judy Davis; isn't she boring?). The whole reason that film works, you could say, is because of Sam Neill: she simply can't accept him. He looks right, but he can't be. No matter how much we love him, and we do, there's always that thing underneath, with him, that he is so delicate in his expression of - that thing that says, even while you know that he is a large man for portraying it, "I will be small, smaller than you, smaller than your world." And that's why your academic didn't work out.

I thought your read on Harvey Keitel in Taxi Driver was amazing. I wanted more, though - more solidity - but maybe that's just it, no more solidity, he simply isn't solid. That performance is a shimmering thing. Of course the whole movie is a shimmering thing. You could write a book about that.

But what about Jimmy Stewart? As much as you have articulated the whys and wherefores of devotion to Gerard Depardieu which I have carried since I was in school and went to see Préparez Vos Mouchoirs (and you have: I think it is his soul; his happiness, and his soul; his gusto, pain, and soul), you have let us all down badly on the Rear Window front! You know, Jimmy Stewart taught me a great big life lesson. You know that amazing drunk scene with him and Cary Grant in The Philadelphia Story? It's astonishing, isn't it: like ballet. Well, somebody interviewed him about it, saying how did you do that great thing, and Stewart answered that the one thing you have to remember when you play a drunk is that all drunks are trying to act sober.

Brilliant.

And his wonderful voice. And his kind, yet piercing, eyes. Ahh... I really wish you'd written about him.

The other thing I loved, if I'm not giving too much away to anyone who reads this, is the way the book suddenly reveals itself during your Wales sojourn to be modelled on a romantic comedy - of course it is! I know you have little good to say about them earlier on when you deconstruct them from a girls' point of view, but I also feel how you love them. Of course I love them too.

One of the ones you mention, Crossing Delancy, is a movie I thought no one knew about but me; for years I pulled it out whenever I felt low. I'm a little disappointed that you didn't mention Sam the pickle man. He really is the kind of guy: he's totally solid, stable, dependable, but he has flair and imagination. Even with his bad haircut he's sexy. And he's great with her Bubba. A star.

In short, darling, your whole book is like an extended conversation on an evening out over a few bottles of wine with my very best friend, Ms Rational Self-Determinism. That's saying something. And I love her more than anyone else in the world!***

I'm giving her your book on Friday.


* Madame Depardieu and the Beautiful Strangers, Harper Perennial, £7.99 and worth every penny

** I use this word advisedly, because he is a bit like your "handsome" Gregory Peck in a way - now I think of it - though of course a bit sexier, just because he projected himself more that way.

*** Attention my family members plus kids. We'll talk.

2 comments:

Pants said...

Ms Quirke should hire you as her publicist Ms Baroque. Isn't it great though when you get so much out of a book - makes waking up worthwhile.

xxx

Pants

moonrat said...

i love this book. my favorite bit is the keanu reeves analysis (SO spot on!!!!).