Monday, 10 March 2008

us and the dead; or, an entire world in your pocket; or, don't let a mobile phone ruin your movie

Well done the Guardian, for their series on Great Twentieth Century Poets: starting tomorrow they will be including free booklets from the likes of Eliot, Plath, etc, with our morning papers. It would have been nice for the list to be a little less obvious than "Eliot, Larkin, Plath" - maybe "Stevens, Auden, Bishop," or even "MacNeice, Bunting, Stevie Smith" - but it feels churlish to complain.

The series was heralded on Saturday with a plea from Sean O'Brien for the common culture we're losing to the Big Brother generation:

"What saddens me is that, when my friends' daughter reads Eliot, material that had remained until recently common property among educated people - for example, biblical allusion - is a closed book to her, a difficulty that seems to offer her attention no reward. She is by no means alone.

"There are many for whom this problem seems trivial. The word 'relevance' looms - that contemporary fetish, so often brandished to mitigate ignorance and justify a failure of curiosity. I would argue that my friends' daughter and many young people like her suffer a loss of liberty when the past is in effect closed down and the present becomes the measure of all things. Such young people have, in effect, no history, and this being so, their own significance is diminished. The problem is not whether Shakespeare or the Bible or TS Eliot is 'relevant' to them, but whether they can see themselves as part of a continuum, a community extending across history."

Of course, this is precisely what we are losing. I know many even quite well-educated people who have little frame of reference outside the right-now: in the arts, particularly, this becomes scary. We will lose access (talk about 'accessability'!) to the roots of our own culture.

It has been pointed out to me in relation to this that "there's so much more present than there used to be," meaning the good old Information Highway (do we still say that?). My friend is an avid reader of novels, blogs, websites, the news, etc. He's no slouch. And he doesn't get the notion that we're losing anything by not getting the past.

Meanwhile, Information Highway firmly in mind, the Boston Globe takes another slant on the same problem, in an article about the forgotten virtues of plain old boredom (as in, what did you used to do when you were stuck in a traffic jam on the plain old Interstate Highway?):

"Marcel Proust describes his protagonist, Marcel, dunking a madeleine cookie into his teacup.

"'Dispirited after a dreary day with the prospect of a depressing morrow, I raised to my lips a spoonful of the tea in which I had soaked a morsel of the cake', Proust wrote. 'And at once the vicissitudes of life had become indifferent to me, its disasters innocuous, its brevity illusory . . . I had ceased now to feel mediocre, contingent, mortal'.

"Marcel's senses are recalibrated, his experiences deepened, and the very nature of memory begins to reveal itself. But it is only through the strenuous process of clearing his mind and concentrating that his thoughts begin to unfurl completely, immersing him in memory. Had Marcel been holding a silver clamshell phone in his hand instead of the delicately scalloped cookie, perhaps he could have quieted the boredom with a quick game of cellphone Tetris. And had Proust come of age with an iPhone in his hand and the expectation that his entire world fit in his pocket, he may never have written his grandiose novel."

What seems apparent to me is that many people, even in the creative professions - where, let's face it, one might hope to find elastic, intuitive minds - are lacking the ability to make connections - to see something as being "relevant" in the light of something else - to contextualise, in short. Because they've forgotten that we're only a part of the picture. And, with so lilttle white space around them, they've lost the ability to go inside themselves and find their own context.

Anyway, roll on this Guardian series, though it would be nice to see it backed up with recommendations of a few currently-living poets... you know: the canon of tomorrow...

3 comments:

Rachel Fox said...

Hello
I know there is a point to this 'no history' argument and I don't wholly disagree with it...but at the same time I tend to think the Bible, for example, has had more than its fair share of attention and so I, for one, am quite happy to be ignorant as far as biblical allusion is concerned. Call me a low-down piece of trash but I would rather talk about Homer Simpson than Jesus H Christ any old day of the week.
RF

Ms Baroque said...

Well, Rachel, in terms of what's more fun, yes! The great thing about the Simpsons, though - the thing that makes it greater than just another cartoon - is its extraordinary breadth of reference. It gambols in the broad sea of our culture like a lamb in a field...

Also, being set in America and a product of America, of course the programme is very concerned with religion. I can't see how anyone could hope to consider themselves seriously engaged with contemporary culture without some understanding of what religion is all about - both historically, and as a driver of our contemporaries in the world.

Knowledge is power. Only through knowing things can we make ourselves free of opression by others, who will exploit our ignorance.

As I said to somebody the other day, this gets corrupted, or reduced, to an argument about past-v-present. But in fact I do think it is just as important to engage with the present. People who don;t get how the world works now are crippled within it. The thing is, we are built on the past: you can't get away from it. So we do have a duty, each of us, to ourselves, to understand it.

The people who write the Simpsons know this, and it is why the show is so great.

Rachel Fox said...

No, I'm not anti-past...not at all..but I do think bits of the past get overstudied. I am much more anti-christ than anti-past.

Also on the Guardian poetry thing...I particularly disliked the use of that old ploy 'getting a woman to be ...oh, you know...non-pc and annoy the feminists (if there are any left)' in the article about only having two women poets in the series and how great that is (quality, quality, quality...). I guess they were wanting some angry letters but I can't be bothered. It just makes me sad...and glad I only read the Guardian when someone else buys it.