Saturday, 30 December 2006

(don't) cry for me

The reaction in Baroque Mansions to the execution of Saddam Hussain is one of such dismay that I have been unable even to organise my thoughts around it properly. The main thrust of my reaction is that the death penalty is a barbarism which corrupts the perpetrators of it far more than it punishes the person on whom it is inflicted. Yes: even more than dying.

I never thought I'd be sad to see Saddam Hussain die, and let me stress that I spare no tears for him now. But there is a humbling aspect to it, as we might do well to remember, especially (as I keep saying) at Christmas. In seeing him die we are forced to remember that he was in fact a human being. The quality of his humanity is not our concern. Our responsibility is to our own humanity.

But just as the governments of the West felt it expedient to meet with this tyrant and shake his hand (as they now shake others; do I need to list them?) they now feel it is meet and seemly to support - even in plases like the UK where there is no death penalty - a punishment which neutralises our stance on his earlier acts. I would have vastly preferred it if we, the West, could have - if only on just this one occasion - acted with dignity and according to our stated beliefs.

Furthermore, the possible outcomes of this particular revenge killing could be dire for all of us.

The bloggers on this occasion have been resonant - though I note a silence in many quarters. Maybe that is because of the season or maybe people have little to add.

Andrew Sullivan's blog, currently being holiday-written by Clive Davis, has an evocative picture and a telling extract from Speer's prison jurnals.

Pictures also seem to be doing the work of thousands of words over on The Sharp Side, where he sums it up with these.

James Higham, at Nourishing Obscurity, brought the Bible to bear, in an understated way - a useful lodestone I think in an arena so dominated by both moral claims and ancient precedent.

Dick Jones, at his Patteran Pages, had explored the issue a day or two before the execution, starting with an apt quote from Gandhi: that, when asked what he thought of Western civilisation, replied that he thought it would be a good idea.

But Francis Sedgemore, trenchant as ever, has gone straight to the point of this barbarity, in both its political and its moral aspects, and its reflection on the part of the UK government as well as others. I particularly like his letter, at the end of his post.

Like Dr Sedgemore I was unedified by the sight of the dictator with a rope around his neck - I hope never to see anyone with a rope around their neck - just as I was appalled by the earlier pictures of him on his capture, and the pictures of his dead sons. Why do we not see that this kind of thing makes us no better than other people who rejoice to see murder carried out?

I too have declined to link to any of the news stories. The press is absolutely not doing justice to the gravity of this event, which is in fact a moral crisis for the civilised West. I will add that, precisely because the West - we - sat back and allowed Saddam to be (in Francis' words) such a "murdering bastard" it becomes us even less to be party to this bloodletting spectacle now that it's all too late. Of course, in a country with the death penalty Saddam would have hung for just one of the many murders he committed or sanctioned. I fail to see what we gain by putting him to death now, when it went so far beyond that.

It could have been a chance to change the terms of the discussion - which has to happen anyway, given the situation in Iraq, though who knows how that will escalate now. We could have risen above the sectarianism that's causing all the problems. We coulda been something.*


*(P-Ump - is that okay?)

10 comments:

Political Umpire said...

Male dominatrix (?) in the Baroque Mansions’ dungeon, wearing a leather catsuit and cracking a whip over the chained Ms B every time she uses an unacceptable film quote (bad girl! Whhhhiiiikkkassshh!!). Unless, of course, you enjoy that sort of thing. In which case, for a substantial hourly fee, I’ll continue. QUIET! You only speak when I tell you. Oh you think it hurts now? Just you wait . . .
What is this war in the heart of nature? Is there an avenging power in nature? Does nature vie with itself? The land with the sea? (1)

F**ing savages. Do these people ever give up? (2)

The more contact I have with humans, the more I learn (3)

Ok my attempts to write a post using only film quotes isn’t quite working (1 = The Thin Red Line, (2) Apocalypse Now and (3) Terminator II. You need to see them all)

More seriously, I blogged about Saddam’s trial before. In essence, we need to separate the trial from the war, and I concluded that he deserved to be tried and convicted. But the death penalty is a different question. I like your post, but won’t be doing one myself (though will link to yours) for a simple reason. I have never supported the death penalty, and see no reason to make exceptions. Therefore, on entirely separate grounds from any political or moral question surrounding Saddam himself or Britain’s involvement in the war, I opposed the execution.

Ms Baroque said...

Me too.

By the way, what am I doing? Of COURSE it's okay - I was quoting Brando!

Madame Arcati said...

I recalled a piece by George Orwell, The Hanging I think, about his reaction to witnessing an execution in Burma. What struck him most was how the condemned man stepped around a puddle on the way to the gallows: even as his life approached its end, the inner life (or life force) was as vibrant as ever, still alert to something like a puddle. Orwell detested the termination of a life in full flow: he even thought of the man's nails still growing as the trap door gave way.

This is - if we must find a label -humanism at its most acute and essential. Then I recalled the innumerable crimes of Saddam, the sadism, the inventive cruelty, the complete absence of pity. I then thought of Kissinger and his vast, unpunished crimes - how I would countenance his execution given half the chance.

And so by this circuitous route I ended up not feeling anything about Saddam. The world in a moment was less one bastard but not not less one problem.

And as for the newspapers and their gloating photographs and uniform commentary. This tells us everything of the automatons so many journalists become and nothing of the world they write about.

And on that note, Happy New Year!

Political Umpire said...

Good god I see I only cut and pasted in half my message, so that it began in the most bizarre fashion and there was no rational intro to my joke about Baroque dungeons. Trust me, it would otherwise have made perfect sense.

I'm going to quit whilst behind. happy new year x

Ms Baroque said...

LOL so you SAY!

Political Umpire said...

A lesson on cricket, Ms B: the Umpire's decision is always right.

A lesson on life, Ms B: the Umpire's decision is .... well you be the judge.

This was a serious original post, and thus far I've only contributed rubbish. Even after saying I'd quit whilst behind. Another apocalypse now quote 'do these people ever give up'? (It's unbelievably funny in context, which mine isn't).

Political Umpire said...

And happy new year, again, now that it is.

Anonymous said...

I note that the Guardian have today published a still taken from the snuff movie featuring Saddam's execution. The picture, which shows Saddam hanging on the end of the rope, has led me to submit a second complaint the the Guardian Readers' Editor.

Ms Baroque said...

Well done, Francis. I've posted on this - I was so shocked this morning that I didn't buy the paper amd I've been waiting all day to get home so I could use my happy slaps line.

P-Ump, I forgive you. Your comments are never anything other than entertaining and Baroque Dungeons would be much duller without the crack of your whip.

Mme A, well put about the newspapers. Abd I agree with you about Kissinger, but never with the death penalty. It's just yet more evil. No to evil! (as the protesters might say in Sedgemore Close)

Anonymous said...

You may have liked the open letter to Nouri al-Malaki, but the Comment is Free editors didn't. They've published an edited version of my article:

http://commentisfree.guardian.co.uk/francis_sedgemore/2007/01/nouri_almalaki_can_go_to_hell.html

As for the complaints about the Guardian's coverage of the execution, Readers' Editor Ian Mayes has acknowledged them and will devote next Monday's Open Door column to the subject.