Sunday, 5 August 2007

now here's something you don't see every day















He
read his Robert Frost...!

Okay, this has cheered me up - not that I needed cheering. I mean cheered me up about Robert Frost. The thing is, I have often and for long found Frost a little offputting - a little austere - a little off the baroque wavelength, dazzling as much of his work is (once you get the straw out of his mouth in your mind). But this anecdote makes me think the old man might have been a little more baroque than he liked to let on:

"Frost’s grasp of fact, as most of us understand the word, could be shaky. During the years when he practiced chicken farming, he occasionally wrote articles for the journal Farm Poultry. One such, published in 1903 and entitled “Three Phases of the Poultry Industry,” alluded to a neighbor’s geese and declared, “Mr. Hall’s geese roost in trees even in the winter.” It’s a nice solid Frostian sentence but utterly incorrect, and a concerted cluck of outrage from indignant chicken-farmers ensued. Frost made things worse by brazening his error out. In rebuttal he said, “What more natural, in speaking of geese in close connection with hens, than to speak of them as if they were hens?” This was fanciful enough, but Frost made it worse by arguing that “‘roost in the trees’ has here simply suffered what the grammarians would call attraction from the subject with which it should be in agreement to the one uppermost in the mind.” The poultry farmers of New Hampshire failed to appreciate such grammatical sophistries and Frost’s career as a poultry correspondent came to an ignominious end."

This comes from Eric Ormsby's review, in The New Criterion, of Frost's Notebooks, but I think it was quoted from a biography (written by Lawrance Thompson).

9 comments:

rilly super said...

Oh dear, I can't read that chaps chest, must be out of practice, but your froideur towards RF makes me think not of any lives of the poets type anecdotes but of Paul Simon singing 'you read your emily dickinson and I my robert frost', but that, as they say, says more about me than about you, sigh

Ms Baroque said...

Okay Rilly, try that - I was being too clever with the links. Click on the pic now and you should be able to read it.

rilly super said...

thanks Ms baroque, I had to look closely at his chest still, but I didn't mind

My husband actually has a poem tattoed on his chest, from when we first began converting our cottage: 'he stared at the ruin, ruin stared back' it says, which apaprently is american too, oh well, he can't take it off now, sigh...

Glamourpuss said...

I've always been more of a bantam fancier myself...

Puss
(thought I should drop directly rather than chat through Quinky)

Anonymous said...

Where are the guy's nipples, ribs, muscles and hair? Tattooing doesn't usually remove all of those things.

Uncle Dick Madeley said...

This Frost sounds like my kind of chap.

Ms Baroque said...

Rilly dear, as long as it's the cottage that's the ruin I think you're all right...

Puss, nice to see you! And very good.

Anon, hm. Well I said it was the kind of thing you don't see every day! Maybe they're all just out of frame.

Dick, I bet he was. Maybe you should look out those back issues, collect some turn-of-the-last-century poultry facts. Nice to see you.

Anonymous said...

He's got no bloody nipples! Eeeewwww...

Ms Baroque said...

I know, Edmond, I know... you'll have me sighing like Rilly, next...